Before I became a mom, I expected the sleepless nights. I expected the crying, the feeding struggles, the exhaustion, and the constant wondering if I was doing enough. What I didn’t expect was how many people would suddenly have an opinion about my baby—or how quickly some of those opinions would turn into people acting like they knew him better than I did.
Everyone seems to have something to say.
He’s tired.
He’s hungry.
He should be sleeping more.
He should be sleeping less.
You hold him too much.
You should put him down more.
He needs this.
He doesn’t need that.
You should try this.
You shouldn’t be doing that.
And sometimes, the comments come from people who genuinely mean well. I know that. But intention doesn’t always change the impact. Because when you’re a new mom already questioning yourself constantly, hearing someone challenge the decisions you’ve spent hours thinking about can feel less like advice and more like criticism. And what I didn’t expect most of all was the feeling that some people don’t just have opinions about your baby—they feel entitled to him.
You See a Moment. I See the Whole Picture.
One of the hardest parts for me is realizing how quickly people form an opinion based on a tiny snapshot of my son.
They see him for ten minutes.
I know what his entire day has looked like.
I know how much he ate.
I know whether he slept well.
I know how long he has been awake.
I know which cry means he is tired and which one means he wants to be held.
I know what his feeding challenges look like. I know what we have tried. I know what specialists have told us. I know what works for him and what doesn’t.
None of that makes me a perfect mom. But it does mean there is usually a reason behind the choices I make. And sometimes, I wish people would ask before assuming.
There is such a difference between: “Why are you doing that?” and “Is there a reason you do it that way?”
One feels like judgment. The other feels like curiosity.
A Moment That Stuck With Me
I was out shopping with a family member recently, and we were out longer than expected. My baby was getting tired, so I held him and rocked him so he would fall asleep. I knew exactly what would happen if I put him down in the stroller at that moment—he would wake up.
I’ve learned his patterns. I’ve lived his patterns.
I was trying to protect a nap so the rest of the day wouldn’t unravel. But my family member said, “Why don’t you set him down in the stroller so he can sleep?” I explained that I was holding him because I knew he would wake up.
She challenged me.
And I was so tired of people thinking they knew better than I did that I gave in and tried it her way. He woke up immediately. He would not fall back asleep. That short interruption turned into a 15-minute cat nap, and the rest of the day was completely derailed. And in that moment, I wasn’t just frustrated about a nap.
I was frustrated that I had been made to doubt what I already knew about my own baby.
Parenting Has Changed
Another thing I have struggled with is advice from people who haven’t had a baby in ten, twenty, or thirty years. And I say this with respect, because experience absolutely matters. But parenting recommendations change.
Safe sleep guidance changes.
Feeding recommendations change.
Car seat safety changes.
What we know about infant development changes.
Even the way we understand attachment, overstimulation, sleep, and responsive parenting has evolved.
So when someone says, “Well, we did that and you turned out fine,” it doesn’t always feel reassuring. Sometimes it just feels dismissive. Because the goal shouldn’t be to prove that an old way was wrong. The goal should be to understand that parents today are working with different information.
Sometimes It Isn’t Even About the Baby
This is the part I think bothers me the most. Sometimes unsolicited advice isn’t actually about helping the baby. Sometimes it is about what is easiest for everyone else. People want to hold the baby even when he is overstimulated. They want to keep him awake because they haven’t seen him long enough. They want you to change a routine because your routine is inconvenient for them. They take boundaries personally. And suddenly, you are expected to prioritize an adult’s feelings over your baby’s needs. That is where I have started drawing a harder line.
My son is not responsible for making adults feel included.
He does not need to stay awake because someone wants more time with him. He does not need to be passed around because people feel entitled to hold him. He does not need his routine disrupted so someone else can feel satisfied. And I don’t need to feel guilty for protecting what I know works for him. I also don’t need to feel like I have to “earn” help or connection by making it easier for others to see him. If someone wants to meet my baby, they can reach out to us and coordinate it. We are new parents. We are still figuring out our days, our rhythms, our sleep, our sanity.
We should not be given extra tasks just to make someone else’s life more convenient.
Motherhood Already Comes With Enough Doubt
There are days when I question everything.
Was that wake window too long?
Did he eat enough?
Should I have let him nap longer?
Was he overstimulated?
Am I responding too quickly?
Am I creating bad habits?
Am I doing this right?
That internal dialogue is already loud.
The last thing a new mom needs is a chorus of outside voices making her feel like she cannot trust herself. There is a strange confidence people seem to have when talking to mothers. Advice gets handed out freely. Boundaries get debated. Parenting decisions become group discussions. And somewhere in all of that noise, the actual mother can start to feel like the least trusted person in the room.
Support Sounds Different
I think we need to rethink what supporting a new mom actually looks like. Support is not correcting every decision. Support is not immediately comparing her baby to yours. Support is not telling her what worked for you as if it is guaranteed to work for her.
Support can sound like:
“Do you want advice, or do you just need to vent?”
“What works best for him?”
“How can I help make things easier?”
“You know him better than I do.”
Sometimes the most supportive thing you can say to a mom is simply:
“I trust you.”
Because there is something incredibly powerful about being reminded that you are allowed to know your own child.
I’m Learning to Trust Myself
I am still figuring motherhood out. I probably always will be. There will always be things I don’t know. There will always be moments when I need advice. And I am incredibly grateful for the people who offer guidance with kindness, curiosity, and respect. But I am also learning that I don’t have to accept every opinion that is handed to me. I don’t have to explain every choice. I don’t have to defend every routine. And I don’t have to make someone else comfortable at the expense of what I believe my son needs. Because I am with him every day. I am learning him in a way no one else can.
His sounds.
His expressions.
His patterns.
His preferences.
His needs.
And maybe one of the biggest lessons of motherhood is learning to turn down the volume on everyone else long enough to hear your own instincts again.
To the new mom surrounded by opinions:
You are allowed to listen.
You are allowed to ask questions.
You are allowed to change your mind.
And you are also allowed to say:
“Thank you, but this is what works for us.”
0 comments